Article: “Leadership Styles and leadership outcomes in nursing homes: a cross-sectional analysis”

This article is based on a cross-sectional study conducted in 6 Belgian nursing homes and on the influence of head nurses and directors of nursing regarding leadership. There were 302 staff members within the nursing home who collaborated as sample subjects, using a multifactor leadership questionnaire (measuring extra effort, effectiveness, and satisfaction) that visualized transformational, transactional, and passive-avoidant leadership styles.

The researchers found that head nurses and directors of nursing were reluctant to use a transformational or transactional leadership style. On the contrary, the passive-avoidant style scored higher in the questionnaire, showing a predominance of this style.

The environment in residential care facilities – also called nursing homes – is complex because most patients would prefer to be in their own home but difficulties in obtaining optimal medical care create the need for a 24/7 specialized treatment. Furthermore, staff tend to suffer from work overload, time-pressure, low wages and job satisfaction, high employee turnover, and poor management, which naturally results in low quality of service provided and reduced safety for the patients.

This is increasingly related to the leadership style adopted (depending on leader’s behaviour) which vary if it is:

a)       Transformational style

               Leaders motivates the team to do more than expected by increasing morale and commitment by:

    •         Idealized influence attributed and behaviour: working on trusting relationships an acting with integrity in a common mission.
    •          Individualized consideration: supporting and coaching group members.
    •          Inspirational motivation: motivating the team with an inspiring vision.
    •          Intellectual stimulation: trust in the abilities of the team to identify problems and solve them.

b)      Transactional style

                Leaders focus on the “exchange” between themselves and the team. The main components are:

    •          Contingent reward: the leader clarifies roles and tasks, rewarding according to task completion.
    •          Active management by exception: monitoring work to take corrective action in case of error.

c)       Passive-avoidant leadership.

    •          Passive management-by-exception: avoidance of leadership.
    •          Laissez-faire: absence of leadership

However, expectations can be different from perceptions of leadership that change depending on various factors (e.g., educational level) Despite the predominant results of the passive-avoidant style – probably used as a survival strategy due to the excess of work and scarce resources – the recommendation was to try to follow transformational leadership (relation-oriented) due to substantial deficiencies found in systematic reviews of previous studies.

It makes sense to think about using the passive-avoidant leadership style as a survival strategy, consciously or unconsciously, by management positions in nursing homes as a result of work overload and scarcity of resources. After all, we are all human. But, although it may seem like a logical response in front of a negative stimulus (similar to procrastination) it is not appropriate to use it at all, especially if medical care is compromised; patients at nursing homes are in a vulnerable position and need special care in a proper way, without being neglected. It is a major problem that needs a systematic approach to solve, which could include government policies to encourage people to pursue careers in health care and efforts to increase salaries, just to name a few.


Article:

Poels, J., Verschueren, M., Milisen, K. et al. Leadership styles and leadership outcomes in nursing homes: a cross-sectional analysis. BMC Health Serv Res 20, 1009 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12913-020-05854-7



Comments

  1. Darvin CrisostomoNovember 15, 2023 at 8:59 PM

    the blog post discusses a Belgian nursing home study revealing a predominant passive-avoidant leadership style, possibly due to work overload and resource scarcity. I very much agree with the suggestion to shift to transformational leadership, emphasizing the need for systematic solutions, including government policies and increased salaries, to address challenges and ensure proper patient care.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Leadership Styles

Image
 Leadership Styles Article Summary After reading the article from Journal of Contemporary Education Theory and Research related to “Leadership styles in special Education ” – which it is pretty recent considering it is coetaneous to Covid-19 crisis – two different leadership approaches stood out:   1)      Transformational leadership, and  2)    Democratic leadership. The article relates to qualitative research whose subjects to study were school principals and teachers in Greece, with the objective of examine their degree of job satisfaction depending on the leadership stated for their schools. There were questionnaires with close-ended questions filled out by 69 teachers in special schools and the results were stunning: they all preferred to work in an environment with a principal that promoted autonomy among the staff, being perceived as motivational and as an inspiration to do their job. This was related to the transformational approach, but also the same effect occurred when
Read more

Leadership Styles and Nurses’ Job Satisfaction

Image
Article Summary: “Leadership Styles and Nurses’ Job Satisfaction. Results of a Systematic Review” In healthcare organizations, leadership results major because it affects all actors interacting (nurses, patients, doctors, families, employees) and determine quality indicators of health services. So, why centered the study in nurses? Because they represent the largest professional body of workers within healthcare systems, playing a key role in quality standards, patient satisfaction, and employee turnover. The cited article studied nurses, job satisfaction, and leadership styles in organizations throughout the systematic review of 12 studies – over 11,813 revised in English and Italian – showing that leadership styles linked nurses to job satisfaction in an 88%.  The research question included (a) nurses working in hospitals, (b) uses of diverse leadership styles by nurse coordinators/managers/leaders, and (c) the effects of nurses’ satisfaction. The leadership styles  analyzed  
Read more
Image
  Leadership Styles and Psychological Empowerment: A Meta-Analysis What is Psychological Empowerment? It is a topic of Organizational Research that gives advantages to companies when acquiring and sustaining competitive positions within markets, and also benefits employees: leads to a proactive and motivated orientation at work. It comprehends 4 work- related conditions:  Competence : self-efficacy of an employee, convincing themselves of having positive skills for high performance. Meaning : employees identify with the company’s objectives and feel that they can execute the work. Self-determination : perception of freedom to decide when to start or finish a task. Impact : belief in having influence on goals at work. Relationship between Leadership and Psychological Empowerment The study analysed 4 styles and their impact, dividing them by high, medium and low matches: Empowering Leadership : idea of power sharing, delegation of authority and resources, encouraging freedom. It
Read more